(503) 974-4299

You Don’t Need a Grand Piano to Start 

6 things to know about your first piano or keyboard

Most people (myself included) fall in love with the piano when they hear that dreamy and classic grand piano. Unfortunately, not everyone can afford one, and it can easily dissuade you in your musical pursuit altogether. Settling for that plastic, less than $50 keyboard isn’t the most ideal, but sometimes it’s the only option.

What I’ve learned in my years of playing a wide variety of keyboards and pianos is that there is almost always a doable balance when it comes to quality and affordability. You have to spend a little to actually enjoy what you practice on, but there’s no need to go overboard – and sometimes spending more doesn’t always result in quality feel or sound.

So, what is actually worth considering when shopping for your first instrument?

Here are the top 6 things I look for when picking out the right piano for me

  1. How does the piano feel?

Enjoying your instrument has about 90% to do with how it feels when you play it. If the keys are extremely lightweight plastic, the effort you put in doesn’t directly translate to the sound emitted. It can get boring or frustrating very quickly when there’s very little room to express yourself on an instrument like that, and self-expression is the best part of playing any instrument. My recommendation would be to find something with weighted keys. Your instrument should always feel good to play.

  1. What features does it have? 

Second to having weighted keys, the most valuable feature to look for is the full 88 keys for maximum range. Hitting those high, bright or low, bass-y notes is most of the fun.

Most acoustic (and many digital) pianos will typically have a set of three pedals (the sustain, practice, and soft pedal). Sometimes keyboards will too, but less often. I suggest you always go with pedals vs. without. There’s a lot of variety in sound and feel you can get out of them, and it’s also way more fun. If you’re interested in a keyboard that doesn’t have a pedal, many have plug-in options so you can buy one separately. I will list some pedal options at the end along with compatible keyboards. 

What are the different pedals and what do they do?

The right (sustain, or damper) pedal lifts the felt dampers off the strings to give your notes a drawn-out, dreamy, connected sound. I’d say this is the most widely used and important pedal to have, and it’s usually the only kind you can get for keyboard plug-in options. 

The middle (sostenuto, or practice) pedal behaves differently between a grand and an upright, and I’ll explain both. 

On a grand and most keyboards, the middle pedal will sustain only the singular note that’s played at the exact same time the pedal is depressed. 

On an upright, the middle pedal mutes the keys when pressed down for quieter, softer playing. The idea is that you won’t disturb others while you practice (hence the term “practice pedal”), but it can also be used as a stylistic choice. You can either continuously hold the pedal down, or press down and shift it into a notch on the left that will hold it in place for you.

The left (soft, or una corda pedal) shifts the entire mechanism/keyboard sideways so the hammers hit fewer strings, creating a softer, quieter tone and timbre. You may want to use this when you get to a gentle or still part of a song.

Other features you may want to consider specifically for a keyboard are input-output ports, built-in metronome, and recording capabilities. A couple of presets are also good fun, but not necessary. I would prioritize having a sustain pedal input and headphone jack over fun presets.

  1. How does it sound?

No matter where you decide to get your piano or keyboard from, always be sure to test it beforehand. This seems pretty self-explanatory when shopping in-person, but you can absolutely do this when shopping online as well. If you’re buying one used from an individual seller, be sure to test all the keys and features first. I’ve suffered too many horrors from seemingly sufficient pianos on the surface all because the person buying it didn’t know to test every key and each pedal. And don’t be afraid to be thorough – your instrument should last you a long time if you take your time and choose wisely. 

Online shops like Amazon have a pretty lenient return policy, so no worries there, but my personal favorite is buying from a place like Guitar Center. Since they have such a wide variety of equipment online and in-store, you can go to your nearest location and test the specific model or type of instrument before you order it online (or get it in-person). 

For pianos, check that all the keys press down easily, don’t get stuck, and produce sound. Even just one or two sticky keys can make a world of difference in your playing. Same goes for the pedals. 

Also, check that it’s properly tuned. Sometimes it’s hard to tell if it’s slightly out of tune, but there are plenty of free apps and programs that can help you check your keys. And if it is slightly out of tune but you really like the piano, no worries – it can be absolutely worth it to hire a piano tuner in your area. If you’re feeling really bold and have the right equipment, you can even learn some basic tuning yourself. 

For keyboards, it’s really a matter of preference. Of course, test all the keys and features to be sure they work, but when it comes to sound, it’s really up to you if you like what you’re hearing. 

  1. Is it comfortable?

Comfort is one of the most important things to look for – right next to price and function. 

Playing a piano, or any instrument, should feel good. And the main factor to feeling comfort or discomfort at your piano is actually your seat. Sitting at an improper height in relation to the keys can cause a lot of back, shoulder, and neck pain – as well as long-term damage. I highly recommend testing different seats with your piano, but the easiest option is to get an adjustable seat. It’s hard to say if something is the proper height until you’ve already put in several hours of practice and begin to experience discomfort. So, if you’re ever in doubt, get the adjustable seat.

I’d also categorize the feel of the keys in comfort, but we already covered that in point #1. Just remember – it should feel good to play your piano.

  1. Does it look nice?

Not super important but something to consider, especially if it’ll be placed in an open or visible area. There are lots of great options if you care about the aesthetic of your setup. Whether you’re looking for the classy, upscale look of a grand, the warm tone of a vintage upright, or even a futuristic, modern take with a sleek keyboard, there’s certainly a choice within your budget.

  1. How much does it cost?

This is the #1 thing people care about when looking for their instrument. Especially if you’re just starting out, I highly endorse used options. There’s lots of really good instruments out there for really affordable prices. Like with many hobbies, people upgrade their current setup or drop it altogether, so you can find a high quality instrument with “low mileage” within your budget. You should absolutely check out places like Offerup and Facebook marketplace.

If you’re absolutely committed, spending some extra money on a baby grand or even a grand piano can be worth it, especially if you’re interested in performing or recording. There’s no sound quite like the real deal. 

That being said, I grew up on a used antique (probably 50+ years old) upright piano that my parents still have – and it sounds incredible. You can absolutely find a beautiful, rich-sounding piano for less than $1,000 for the reason I mentioned before: people upgrade or outgrow their instruments all the time, so there’s lots of great options out there.

I’ve also had really disappointing and frustrating experiences playing on pricey grand pianos – it really comes down to knowing what you’re looking for and staying within your budget. 

The same is true for keyboards, and now is probably the best time to get one. The options are limitless and the quality is the best it’s ever been. 

My top recommendations for keyboards and pianos – brands, prices, and where to get them

Of course, my #1 recommendation is to check local listings near you for used pianos/keyboards. Regardless of what you’re looking for, I always suggest you look there first. Unless you have disposable income or a professional incentive, this is always the way to go. Some people will even list instruments for free as long as you’re willing and able to come pick them up. 

Good places to look are Offerup, Facebook Marketplace, and Craigslist. I got one of my favorite keyboards for less than $100 on Offerup, and it’s in perfect, barely used condition. Guitar Center also carries many lightly used, excellent-condition options.

If you do want to buy new, my favorite places for keyboards are Guitar Center and Amazon, with the most reliable brands being Yamaha, Roland, and Williams.

Here are my top picks for keyboards with links:

Yamaha P-45 Guitar Center / Yamaha P-45 Amazon – added accessories / Yamaha P-45B Amazon 

Yamaha P-225 Guitar Center / Yamaha P-225 Amazon

Yamaha P-143LXB Guitar Center / Yamaha P-143 Amazon / Yamaha P-145BT Amazon

Roland FP-30X Guitar Center / Roland FP-30X Amazon – added accessories – (I’ve recently really fallen in love with this one! The sound is incredible!)

Roland FP-10 Guitar Center / Roland FP-10 Amazon

Williams Allegro IV Guitar Center

KUMENG Amazon

UISCOM Amazon

Ktaxon Amazon

HEXANT Amazon

And if you’re interested in a grand or upright, here are a few good options to look at:

  • Jim Laabs Music store offers a wide price range, with grands starting around $1,500 and uprights around $750. They also offer rentals. Jimlaabsmusicstore.com 
  • Guitar Center carries a variety of digital grand and upright pianos, with prices ranging from under $1,000 to $20,000. Guitarcenter.com  
  • Music Store offers an excellent selection and competitive prices, but it is located in Europe, which means longer shipping times and communication delays for U.S. customers. Musicstore.com 

Be sure to review each company’s return policy, which ranges from approximately 14-45 days, depending on the store.