Part. 1
I had two prominent piano teachers in my life – one who made me love playing the piano, and one who was the reason that I stopped taking lessons altogether.
I stayed with the teacher that I loved for a long time. She nurtured a very healthy bond between us, and she was someone I genuinely looked forward to seeing every week. She was young – in her early 20’s, and didn’t have a studio or website or anything like that at the time. She would teach out of her family home while also putting herself through college. I am the age she was now, and I still think of her with much fondness. She was an incredibly kind, warm, and fun person – she always put creating a happy and healthy relationship first. I was a student of hers for around 8 years, and I never got sick of it. Sure, there were times I’d lose motivation or get discouraged, but I didn’t want to let her down. I wanted her to be proud of me, so I never gave up.
My lessons with her ended when she got married and moved away, and I was pretty broken up about it.
I took a break from lessons, but my mom eventually signed me up with another teacher in the area. This teacher was older, had many more years of experience, and worked out of a nice studio. She had many students, would host extravagant recitals, and was well-known in the area. I stuck with her for a year before I begged my mom to let me quit. This teacher, while very experienced and knowledgeable, felt lifeless in comparison to my previous teacher. There was no warmth, no great concern for teacher/student relationship, and didn’t exude passion. I’m sure she loved what she did and was good at it, but I didn’t sense it and my own passion fizzled out.
I dropped out, and haven’t taken any more lessons since then.
I do not regret this decision since I continued to play for church and family, and later renewed my love for piano on my own. But I think about my two teachers often and the difference between them. It all comes down to teaching style and philosophy. One valued personal connection and making learning enjoyable, while the other valued business.
Educator Rita Pierson once said in her famous Ted Talk, Every Kid Needs a Champion, “Kids don’t learn from people they don’t like.” I’m a very firm believer in that.
Part. 2
I was talking with my mom the other day, and she shared a similar story with me. She grew up in Ukraine at a very difficult time, so it’s hard to come up with many warm memories of being a child during that time and place. But one particular school memory stood out.
She was never extremely involved in her schoolwork – her own words were, “I was a very medium student.” Life at home left little time or energy for homework, and most subjects didn’t interest her anyway. Biology was the exception — she’d always been curious about nature, people, and life.
Unfortunately, her biology teacher hated her. This was back at a time when it was more socially acceptable to openly dislike or bully someone based on their class, and my mom was no stranger to this treatment. The kids that came from richer, nicer families got the special treatment and good grades, so no amount of effort on my mom’s part ever seemed to matter. She always got bad grades, even when she studied hard.
One day, her teacher left on a trip for a few months, and was replaced with a substitute who was new to the school. On top of being overall more caring, this teacher didn’t have any preconceived notions about any of the students, so her grading was based solely on their performance. This new teacher treated my mom fairly and with the kindness that every child deserves. While my mom’s studying habits didn’t change (at first), her grades did. C’s and D’s suddenly became A’s and B’s.
That’s when things really shifted. She started making time for biology homework, actually enjoyed it, and even looked forward to school for the first time.
A big test came up, and she studied hard — not just to pass, but to do well. On the day of the test, the substitute teacher made an announcement. The top five students with the best grades would be excused from taking the test and get an automatic A. My mom didn’t think anything of it, but as the teacher called out the top students, she was stunned to hear her name. She was excused! All her hard work finally paid off, and for the first time ever, she was rewarded and got “special” treatment. So, instead of taking the tedious test, she and the other top students got to enjoy an ice cream and walk around the schoolyard. She felt on top of the world.
Then, the fateful day came. The original biology teacher returned from her trip, and the substitute left the school. Without any warning or change in effort, my mom’s grades suddenly went back to C’s and D’s, and her love for the class quickly died. She no longer had the passion to study like she had been, and she no longer looked forward to going to school.
Decades later, she still remembers both teachers clearly, and still thinks fondly of that substitute. A good teacher can be the difference between a kid caring about something or not — and can make almost any subject interesting.
Part. 3
When I think back to college, there are two professors who really stand out to me—each for the opposite reason.
The first was my pre-calculus teacher. I’ve never loved math, never been particularly good at it, and honestly dreaded it when I was younger. But in college, I took it seriously. I studied late into the night, memorized formulas, practiced for tests, took meticulous notes, and never skipped class.
But I still sucked. Pretty bad.
I considered dropping the class more than once because I didn’t think I’d pass. The only reason I toughed it out was probably because my professor was a super cool dude and gave me hope. (Thanks, Mr. A!)
On the day of the final, I was worried sick. I had studied endlessly, but when I sat down to take the test, I suddenly couldn’t remember anything. There was one problem I knew I should have been able to solve, but I couldn’t remember the formula. I put down an answer and moved on. After I finished, I handed the test to Mr. A and walked out. As I left the building, the answer suddenly came back to me. I actually knew it! So I ran back to the classroom and explained what happened. I swore I hadn’t cheated and looked it up. Mr. A looked me in the eyes and said, “I believe you.” He handed the test back and let me fix the problem.
When we got our grades, I discovered I had passed by such a small margin that the one problem he let me correct likely made the difference. That class probably had very little impact on the overall trajectory of my life, but Mr. A’s kindness and belief in me have stuck with me ever since. He genuinely cared about his students and wanted to see them succeed.
The same cannot be said for my other professor, who shall not even begin to be named.
I took a Roman history class expecting to learn a lot. After the first day, half the class dropped out, and some people even left crying.
The professor knew his stuff. He was incredibly knowledgeable and had obviously studied the subject for years. But he didn’t want to see people succeed. He was bitter, hateful, and seemed to think being a “tough” professor meant making his students miserable. I probably should have dropped the class, but I stuck it out with the help of a very good friend I met there. We studied together and bonded over the insanity. That is the only reason I tolerated or passed that class.
A year or two after I graduated, I saw my Roman history professor at the grocery store. He had a big cast on his leg, probably broken.
I’m not proud of it, but I remember thinking, “Yes! That’s karma, baby!”
Mr. A and my Roman history professor were both knowledgeable and experienced. The difference was that one cared about his students and their success, while the other didn’t. One loved teaching and genuinely cared. The other used his position as some weird power play over helpless students.
Be like Mr. A.
And don’t be afraid to drop a class that makes you absolutely miserable. It will not ruin your life.
Probably.